Error reported fixed in Errata02 but not actually fixed in Spec

There's an error in these documents that has slipped through. I don't think we can just ignore it, because we SAID in Errata 02 that we fixed it, but in actuality we did not. I flagged this in the DITAweb review, but I think Kris misinterpreted my comment and rejected it.

 

The topic is "2.2.3.4 Processing controlled attribute values"

 [source file is \specification\archSpec\base\processing-controlled-attribute-values.dita]

 

Output text as it appeared in Spec+Errata01 (also seen in the "Original text" column of the big change-table of Errata02):

                If "therapist" is flagged and "novice-therapist" is not explicitly flagged, processors automatically should flag "novice" since it is a type of therapist.

 

Output text as it is supposed to be corrected in Spec+Errata02 (also seen in the "Revised text" column of the big change-table):

                If "therapist" is flagged and "novice-therapist" is not explicitly flagged, processors automatically should flag "novice-therapist" since it is a type of therapist.

 

Markup currently in Errata02 branch of source in github (this is consistent with the output as rendered in the XHTML and PDF output produced by Bob today):

 

<li>If "therapist" is flagged and "novice<ph rev="errata-02">-therapist</ph>" is not

explicitly flagged, processors automatically should flag "novice" since it is a type of

therapist.</li>

                                                                  

The correct markup should be:

 

<li>If "therapist" is flagged and "novice-therapist" is not explicitly flagged, 

processors automatically should flag "novice<ph rev="errata-02">-therapist</ph>" 

since it is a type of therapist.</li>

 

mag

 

 

 

From:  [mailto:] On Behalf Of Robert Thomas
Sent: January 17, 2018 9:45 AM
To: 
Subject: [dita] Groups - All XHTML for public review 23 January 2018 uploaded

 

Submitter's message
All XHTML .zips for the 23 January 2018 public review of Errata02 
-- Mr. Robert Thomas 

Document Name: All XHTML for public review 23 January 2018

No description provided. 
Download Latest Revision
Public Download Link

Submitter: Mr. Robert Thomas
Group: OASIS Darwin Information Typing Architecture (DITA) TC
Folder: Drafts
Date submitted: 2018-01-17 09:43:56