Goran,
Thanks for sending these documents - it's clear that a
great deal of work has gone into them.
I
have a few questions, please:
Run-Time SOA: I get the notion of a reference
architecture as shown in Figure 1 on p.3. Having said that, I would expect that
any run-time (concrete) architecture that is depicted as being based on the
reference architecture is merely for exemplary purposes, yet the run-time
architecture is simply presented without any indication of its purpose. Since
the run-time architecture is greatly concrete, is it intended that products be
based on it? Is it intended for exemplary purposes? Other?
SOA Information Model: Though this is called a "SOA"
information model, this document looks more to me like a
"Process Information Model" that is actually independent of SOA (that is, I did
not see anything that restricted it to SOA). In
fact, in order to call something a "SOA" information model, I would assert that
there are several other areas that would need to be incorporated beyond
processes - e.g. security, policy, QoS, etc. Even considering the process
perspective, there is nothing that I see in this information model that speaks
distinctly to a service-oriented paradigm - in fact, figure 1 (p.24) does not
even have a "Service" concept. What is the intended use of this document for
ebSOA?
Thanks,
Joe
Joseph Chiusano
Associate
Booz Allen Hamilton
700 13th St. NW
Washington, DC 20005
O: 202-508-6514
C: 202-251-0731
Visit us online@ http://www.boozallen.com
From: Goran Zugic
[mailto:]
Sent: Friday, October 21, 2005
2:21 AM
To: 'ebSOA OASIS TC'
Subject: [ebsoa] SOA
Collaboration Semantics
Hello
ebSOA TC,
Semantion is pleased to announce the completion of its FERA-based SOA
contribution to ebSOA TC.
The SOA Collaboration Semantics document
http://www.semantion.com/specs/soa/SOA_CS_V0.1.doc
contains FERA-based SOA semantics specification that together with two
previously submitted documents, Run-time SOA and SOA Information
Model, represent Semantion's SOA specification framework.
The new
releases of the Run-time SOA document and the SOA Information
Model document are available at
http://www.semantion.com/specs/soa/SOA_IM_V0.2.doc
http://www.semantion.com/specs/soa/Run-time_SOA_V0.2.doc
These documents should be reviewed in the following
order:
- Run-time SOA
- SOA Information Model
- SOA Collaboration Semantics
Please let me know if you have any questions or need more information
regarding the submitted documents.
Regards,
Goran
Zugic
Chief
Architect
Semantion
Inc.
http://www.semantion.com
416-995-7532
