Re: [ebxml-iic] about 3.5 in spec

Title: about 3.5 in spec

Jacques and all,

 

 Please see my comments below.   
Also, I've attached V0.95 based on comments below.

 

Regards,

Mike

 

  
----- Original Message ----- 

  
From: 
  Jacques 
  Durand 

  
To: '' 
  

  
Sent: Tuesday, September 23, 2003 9:22 
  PM

  
Subject: [ebxml-iic] about 3.5 in 
  spec

  

  
Mike: 

  
Looking again at 3.5 in the conformance spec, I 
  feel we cannot just take it out 
and move it 
  to the non normative executable test suite: 
a lot in it is directly relevant to the abstract test cases: 

  
 

  
[MIKE] - I agree, only portions need to be moved to 
  executable test suite document.

  
 

  
Section 3.5.1: is really T.Fmk-dependent (does not 
  belong in the normative part of the spec) 

  
[MIKE] - Agreed and moved

  
 

  

3.5.2: just need a more "abstract" version of 
  it in the test suite spec, not referencing T.Fmk 1.0. 
(remove ref to Test Driver) 

[MIKE] - Agreed and changed
  

3,5,4: seems relevant to abstract test 
  suite...as the mapping to CPA is part of defining the test suite. 
  

[MIKE] - Agreed 
  

3.5.5: these CPA specifications are also part 
  of the abstract test suite: they are referenced by 
the abstract test cases. 

  
 

  
[MIKE] - Agreed and modified

  
So maybe it only needs a light clean-up. table in 
  3.5.2 can be moved 
to executable doc, but I 
  feel a more abstract version of it (removing Test Driver column...) is still 
  be needed here. 

  
[MIKE] Agreed, removed pertinent columns that 
  pertain to Test Driver/Test Framework ( last 3 columns )

  
 

  
Opinion? 

  
Jacques 

IIC_MS_Conformance_TestSuite_V0.95.doc