RE: [ebxml-msg] Messaging Spec v1.092

From
Ralph Berwanger
Date
2002-01-04T14:03:00+00:00
ID
Thread
RE: [ebxml-msg] Messaging Spec v1.092
David,
     I must disagree with you on item 9.  It makes NO sense  to return a signed receipt for a document that did not contain an original  signature.   I know that the intent is to provide the message  originator with some sense of security; however, it is not really achieved and  it may in fact provide them a false sense of security. They may assume that  the signed receipt makes a legal statement that it cannot make.  This is  not a technical issue, it is a legal and business issue--we will do the  community a disservice if we support signed receipts for unsigned messages.I  have been around this argument many times with the same  findings.

Ralph  Berwanger