Re: [id-cloud] Need a problem fixed for Identity In The Cloud Gap Analysis V1.0

Since this is the first public review,
      we can list all members.  In subsequent reviews, we can trim down
      the list if anyone wants to be removed.

      

      On 04/25/2013 12:12 PM, Chet Ensign wrote:

    

    
      
It is really up to the TC. Best way I have seen it
        done is to just ask the TC if any members (not observers by the
        way) do not want to be included but otherwise list all members. 
        

        

        
/chet

      

      

        

        
On Thu, Apr 25, 2013 at 1:02 PM,
          Gershon Janssen <>
          wrote:

          
            

              

              

              Hi Chet,
              

                

                

                
> list
                    of people who participated in the development of the
                    Work Product.

                

                  

              

              
What
                  is the best way to compile this list?

              

              

              
Full roster? Active
                  participants of the TC during the period the Work
                  Product has been developed? I can deliver all details,
                  but some guidance is helpful.

              

                

              
Regards,

              

                

              
Gershon Janssen

              

                

                  

                    

                  

                    

                    
On Thu, Apr 25, 2013 at
                      6:07 PM, Chet Ensign <>
                      wrote:

                      
                        
Members of the ID-Cloud TC, 
                          

                          

                          
I must ask you to do a bit more work on Identity In The
                              Cloud Gap Analysis Version 1.0 before we
                              can proceed with the preparation of the
                              document and the public review. 

                          

                              

                          
The
                                draft presented does not have any
                                acknowledgements. The acknowledgements
                                section is required by Sect. 2.18 of the
                                TC Process: "Acknowledgements.
                              Any Work Product that is approved by the
                              TC at any level must include a list of
                              people who participated in the development
                              of the Work Product. This list shall be
                              initially compiled by the Chair, and any
                              Member of the TC may add or remove their
                              names from the list by request." 

                          

                              

                          
While
                                fixing that you might as well remove the
                                empty Appendix B. 

                          

                              

                          
Please
                                add the acknowledgements to Appendix A,
                                re-approve the CND for public review and
                                send us the link to the minutes with the
                                approval motion. I will keep the
                                existing tickets open and update them
                                when I get the updated information from
                                you. 

                          

                              

                          
Thanks
                                very much and let me know if you have
                                any questions on this. 

                          

                              

                          
Best
                                regards, 

                          

                            

                              

                          
/chet 

                          
----------------

                            Chet Ensign

                            Director of Standards Development and TC
                            Administration 

                            OASIS: Advancing open standards for the
                            information society

                            http://www.oasis-open.org

                            

                            Primary: +1
                              973-996-2298

                            Mobile: +1
                              201-341-1393 
                            

                            

                            
Check your work using the Support
                              Request Submission Checklist at http://www.oasis-open.org/committees/download.php/47248/tc-admin-submission-checklist.html 

                              

                              TC Administration information and support
                              is available at http://www.oasis-open.org/resources/tcadmin