RE: [kmip-interop-tech] Updated Graphs

From
Stephen Edwards <>
Date
2019-02-20T13:14:00+00:00
ID
Thread
RE: [kmip-interop-tech] Updated Graphs
I thought the point of the graphs was to provide a visual representation of conformance to the standard, not the number of products submitted for testing.


  -Steve
From:   <>
  On Behalf Of  Tim Hudson
  Sent:  Wednesday, February 20, 2019 7:07 AM
To:  
Subject:  Re: [kmip-interop-tech] Updated Graphs



  On Wed, Feb 20, 2019 at 9:58 PM John Leiseboer < 
> wrote:

I don t think changing the labels makes the graphs any less misleading. Graphs 1 and 2 present exactly the same information and are more than sufficient.

John



  I don't see how you can simultaneously claim the graphs are misleading
  and    that they contain  exactly the same information  as two graphs that are not misleading.

  That position is simply not tenable.



  The graphs are completely accurate and represent the activity in the testing and are based on results we have all confirmed are accepted as accurate.



  For people that don't read the graph titles and the labels, or elect to read things out of context, Tony has updated the labels to make it clear what number of products are including in the total test results.



  Tim.