Profiles -- How much to detail in the charter?

Sander Marechal <>
wrote on 06/20/2008 06:01:03 PM:

> 

> Both Garry Hurley and I don't know if it's possible to set a TC to
work 

> with use-cases and ask "make us something that does this".
Is that 

> possible under OASIS process? How would it work? Should it be in the

> charter? The list of deliverables? A combination of both? What would
the 

> language be like?

> 

You can certainly put something like this in the deliverables
section: "The TC will review current practices pertaining to the development
of profiles for interoperability and produce a report that includes a recommendation
of best practices for the OIIC TC, as well as a prioritized list of profiles
to create."

What I don't want is for our hasty research, and Marbux's
idiosyncratic views, to substitute for a proper review of the state of
the art in profile development.  To do so is rather presumptuous and
could significantly reduce the proposed TC's chances of success.  

-Rob