I agree with Dan. It is difficult to vote on something without an explanation to go along with the pictures. I think the team will need time to review in order to make an informed decision. I would recommend we hold off on voting until the next telecon in two weeks, and that we get a little more information in the meantime.
Thanks,
Kathryn
> ----------
> From: Dan Chang[SMTP:]
> Sent: Wednesday, August 08, 2001 1:07 PM
> To: Lisa Carnahan
> Cc: ; tom Rhodes
> Subject: Re: Call Tomorrow
>
>
> Lisa,
>
> The proposals are definitely an improvement over the existing RIM, since I
> have had concerns about the RIM and have raised issues on it before.
>
> Given the limited information (two figures) available, if we are going to
> vote on them tomorrow, I will vote ABSTAIN simply because I have not had
> the opportunity to review the proposals in their entirety.
>
> I would like to suggest that the proposals be taken up by a sub-team and
> developed/documented in full detail before we vote.
>
> Regards, Dan
>
> e-business Data Technology and Standard
> IBM Silicon Valley Laboratory
> Notes: Dan Chang/Santa Teresa/IBM@IBMUS
> Internet:
> VM: IBMUSM50(DTCHANG)
> Phone: (408)-463-2319
>
>
>
> Lisa Carnahan
> <lisa.carnahan To:
> @nist.gov> cc: tom Rhodes <>
> Subject: Call Tomorrow
> 08/08/01 12:37
> PM
>
>
>
>
>
>
> Hello All,
>
> As many of you know, throughout the ebXML effort Len Gallagher from NIST
> had raised serious concerns regarding the ebXML information model and
> services. Most of these issues were raised prior to our ebXML meeting in
> Vancouver. At that meeting, the committee decided to defer resolution on
> many of these issues until after Phase I. So here we are in Phase II.
>
> As those who attended the Vancouver meeting know, Farrukh Najmi (and
> others) had serious concerns regarding many of Len's issues. It became
> apparent to me that some benefit may be derived if I put Len and Farrukh
> in a room for a day or so to discuss Len's issues. So we did just that.
>
> Last week Len, Farrukh, Nikola Stojanovic, and I met for a day and a half
> to discuss Len's recurring issues. The meeting was extremely productive in
> that many issues were resolved to all parties' satisfaction (sort of).
> The attached file represents two proposals for changing the information
> model and inheritance diagrams for the RIM. (We additionally started a
> list of bugs that were identified during the discussion. I'll provide that
> in a separate message.)
>
> Please recognize that the attached documents do not represent consensus of
> the OASIS/ebXML Registry TC. Currently the attached documents are based on
> the opinions of 3 TC members. (My role was more of a facilitator than a TC
> member.) We will discuss these proposals during the conference call
> tomorrow. These proposals will be accepted only if we achieve positive
> consensus within the TC.
>
> I have a number of other items for the agenda; I'll try and send you email>
> regarding them before the meeting.
>
> Call-in information: NOTE: THIS NUMBER IS DIFFERENT THAN THE LAST CALL.
>
> CALL DATE: AUG-09-2001 (Thursday)
> > CALL TIME: 04:00 PM EASTERN TIME
> > DURATION: 2 hr
> > USA Toll Free Number: 888-566-5920
> > USA Toll Number: +1-630-395-0252
> > PASSCODE: 13852
> > LEADER: Ms Lisa Carnahan
>
> --lisa
>
>
>
> #### object2.gif has been removed from this note on August 08 2001 by Dan
> Chang
> #### public3.gif has been removed from this note on August 08 2001 by Dan
> Chang
>
>
>
>
> ------------------------------------------------------------------
> To unsubscribe from this elist send a message with the single word
> "unsubscribe" in the body to:
>
