K.C.,
Thank you so much for your very accurate comments, and for presenting
these ideas at the ebXML Korea Conference. Please see feedback below.
<Quote1>
In my opinion, the sentence, "There is also the possibility of
discovering an ebXML registry from within UDDI.", should be
written as "There is also the possibility of discovering a UDDI from
within an ebXML registry.".
</Quote1>
You are correct - that is a typo.
<Quote2>
"Additionally, there does not currently exist a standard mechanism for
querying both types of registries at an abstract
level - that is, in which information can be pulled from either a UDDI
registry or ebXML registry using the same query
mechanism on both types of registries.".
As far as I know, we can use the JAXR for querying both types of
registries with each query capability(of course, not the
same query mechanism).
</Quote2>
I definitely should have been more specific about this. What I wanted to
say was that there does not currently exist an open standard
(programming language-agnostic) for doing this. I chose to not mention
JAXR because my intention was to be very high-level and not get into
specific APIs. Thanks for point this out.
Kind Regards,
Joe
Kyu-Chul Lee wrote:
>
> Hi Joe,
>
> I enjoy reading your impressive paper, and I am going to present your idea to the ebXML Korea community
> at the ebXML Korea Conference held on 30th April.
>
> While I am reading the expanded Interoperability section, I am afraid there may be some mistake in the first sentence of
> the 'Additional Possibilities' subsection.
> In my opinion, the sentence, "There is also the possibility of discovering an ebXML registry from within UDDI.", should be
> written as "There is also the possibility of discovering a UDDI from within an ebXML registry.".
>
> And one more thing that I'd like to mention is about the last sentence of the same subsection, i.e.
> "Additionally, there does not currently exist a standard mechanism for querying both types of registries at an abstract level - that is, in which information can be pulled from either a UDDI registry or ebXML registry using the same query mechanism on both types of registries.".
> As far as I know, we can use the JAXR for querying both types of registries with each query capability(of course, not the same query mechanism).
> I think that introducing JAXR to the readers will be more informative.
>
> Kind Regards,
> K.C.
>
> ===================================================================
> Kyu-Chul Lee
> Professor
> Dept. of Computer Engineering, Chungnam National University
> 220 Gung-Dong, Yuseong-Gu
> Daejeon, 305-764, South Korea
> Voice : +82-42-821-6658 FAX : +82-42-822-4997
> Mobile Phone : +82-11-9947-6658
> E-mail : <mailto:>
> URL : http://dblab.ce.cnu.ac.kr/
> ===================================================================
>
> -----Original Message-----
> From: Chiusano Joseph [mailto:]
> Sent: Thursday, April 24, 2003 6:10 AM
> To: Breininger Kathryn R
> Cc: ebXML Regrep (E-mail)
> Subject: Re: [regrep] Booz Allen Hamilton paper online
>
> Thanks Kathryn. I'd like to add a clarification that this is not exactly
> the same paper that I sent to the listserv recently - it has been
> slightly expanded (at the request of the editor) in the Interoperability
> section.
>
> Joe
>
> "Breininger, Kathryn R" wrote:
> >
> > Here is the link to the Booz Allen Hamilton paper Joe authored http://www.webservices.org/index.php/article/articleview/984/1/24/ . (He sent us the PDF version April 1st).
> >
> > Kathryn Breininger
> > CENTRAL Project Manager
> > Emerging Technologies
> > Boeing Library Services
> >
> > 425-965-0182 phone
> > 425-237-3491 fax
> >
