RE: [regrep] UK Government Registry Requirements

From
Peter Kacandes <>
Date
2004-01-15T01:22:19+00:00
ID
Thread
RE: [regrep] UK Government Registry Requirements
Hi All,

I've just been reading a most disturing section 
of a draft document called the UK e-GIF (e Government Interoperability 
Framework):

"2.5    Departments which are connected to the GSI 
are to use the GSI Notice 1/2003 Information GSI Directory Schema, except for 
WEB based transactions over SOAP when UDDI is to be 
used

2.6     When Web services are used they shall to 
be based on SOAP, UDDI and WSDL specifications."

I think we as a 
TC need to make sure that ebXML Registry gets equal billing with UDDI for these 
purposes.

Paul, is there anyway you can put us in touch with appropriate 
contacts to make sure that this gets modified in the next draft of this 
document?

Especially given that other parts of the document talk about 
the importance of meta-data content management:
"Content management metadata
2.19    The 
technical policies for content management metadata cover:

The adoption 
and development of the e-GMS, based on the International Dublin Core model, to 
meet government's information management and retrieval needs

The e-GMS is 
a 'superset' of metadata elements and refinements, and it is unlikely that any 
single system will require all of them. Organisations are therefore encouraged 
to develop sector and system-specific standards, removing elements that are not 
required, and adding local constraints

2.20    The 
development and maintenance of the GCL (Government Category 
List)."

Also in section 2.39 it says:
"For 
example, ebXML uses the international address standard whereas the UK has its 
own address standard."
I'd like to understand what they mean by 
that.

The full document can be found at:
http://www.govtalk.gov.uk/schemasstandards/egif_document.asp?docnum=731

regards

pk

-----Original Message-----
From: 
Paul Spencer [mailto:]
Sent: 
Friday, January 09, 2004 10:29 AM
To: regrep
Subject: [regrep] UK 
Government Registry Requirements

I hope people remember the 
discussions we had last year about this. We got
as far as agreeing to put 
together a document based on the requirements of
the UK MOD and wider 
requirements that others could contribute.

Sorry about the delay (I have 
been tied up with the Election Markup
Language), but I have now done a first 
draft of those parts of the document
that I said that I would do. It is 
at
http://boynings.co.uk/mod/regrep-v0-2.pdf.

The next stage is to add wider requirements and come up with 
a
standards-based architecture to achieve these requirements. My goal is 
to
create an architecture using OASIS standards that can be used to allow 
these
registries to interact, not only within government, but also, for 
example,
with a UBL repository. Although I am talking about the registry 
(which will
obviously use ebXML standards since we are discussing it here) I 
believe
there is a lot we need to decide in terms of how the registry is used 
and
the client applications required. However, it is essential within 
Government
not to specify specific applications to be used.

My hope is 
that people will read this document (it is a PDF, but I am happy
to do other 
formats on request) and we can discuss it at the telecon 
on
Thursday.

Regards

Paul Spencer
Director
Boynings 
Consulting Ltd
http://www.boynings.co.uk

To 
unsubscribe from this mailing list (and be removed from the roster of the OASIS 
TC), go to http://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/regrep/members/leave_workgroup.php.