Final specification and schema versions for e-ballot

Hello all,

 

I have incorporated the non-material changes I enumerated in my recent email (attached) into new versions of the specification and schema, which you can find here:

 

https://github.com/oasis-tcs/sarif-spec/tree/master/Documents/BallotDrafts/sarif-v2.1.0-final-e-ballot-1

 

You will find both a change-barred version of the spec and a version with the changes accepted. In the e-ballot, we will vote on the version with changes accepted.

 

The only changes to the schema are the correction of a few property descriptions (#437,

#445) and a misspelled property name (#449).
 Since I can’t change-bar the schema, you can compare it to 
https://github.com/oasis-tcs/sarif-spec/blob/master/Schemata/sarif-schema-2.1.0.json.

 

Luke: I didn’t address 
#448. Please see the issue for an explanation.

 

I will wait until end of day on Tuesday February 25th for any comments from you, since I don’t want us to have to restart the e-ballot once it’s started. Please review these materials and reply back to the list if you have any questions
 or concerns. After that, I’ll ask David to start the e-ballot.

 

NOTE: There are still places in the boilerplate at the front and in the page footer that refer to this as a “draft”, “working draft”, or “committee specification”. OASIS is responsible for updating those in the final document, so don’t
 worry about it.

 

Best regards,

Larry

 

--- Begin Message ---

From: "Larry Golding (Myriad Consulting Inc)" <>

To: "" <>

Date: Mon, 17 Feb 2020 22:11:04 +0000

We should fix the following non-material issues that have been captured as GitHub issues in

https://github.com/oasis-tcs/sarif-spec:

 

#422: 
 Ensure all GUIDs in format examples are valid but distinguishable

#430:
 Conformance Clause numbering skips clause 4

#431:
 Add xref 3.7.4 to graphTraversal.runGraphIndex

#432:
 Spec restricts link destinations in formatted messages to non-negative integers

#434:
 Clarify that per-sub-rule metadata is not supported

#435:
 Use "document" rather than "specification" as appropriate

#436: 
 Missing curly brace in example

#437:
 Fix result.rule.description in schema

#440:
 Fix typo in 3.14.28 section title

#444:
 Errors in K.4 Comprehensive SARIF file

#445:
 Editorial issue in invocation.startTimeUtc and invocation.endTimeUtc descriptions

#446:
 Invalid Hyperlinks found

#448:
 Duplication of v2.1.0 JSON schema

#449:
 Suppression "status" property mis-spelled as "state" in the schema

#450:
 Use of obsolete baselineState.existing property persists in spec

#451:
 Clarify guidance on use of space in plain text messages

 

Thanks,

Larry

--- End Message ---