From today's call, I had two items to research further, and get back to
the group.
Simon Holdsworth wrote:
For the binding.ws
specification
(wd-02):
p. 8, line 110 - Shouldn't the @uri
attribute take precedence if it exists?
(In wd-03, this is still the same line #).
Question #1 from the conf. call - did we have an issue we have resolved
related to this? Answer - not that I can find.
Question #2 from the conf. call - what precisely did I mean here?
Answer:
I have recalled what I meant, and reviewing the context, I've
discovered that what I meant was simply incorrect. I withdraw the
point.
p. 6, line 55 - should include a
table
showing implied prefix to namespace mappings.
-> Not entirely sure
what
is being asked for here, but not covered by existing issues.
Since I'm here, Simon asked for examples:
W3C: http://www.w3.org/TR/2007/REC-wsdl20-20070626/#nsprefixes
OASIS: See section 1.2 of
http://docs.oasis-open.org/security/saml/v2.0/saml-bindings-2.0-os.pdf
p. 10, line 169 - As
far as JCA specs
specifies the activation spec, it does not specifies the connnection
factory
but the destination. So the line "MUST NOT ..." does not apply
here.
-> Requires further
discussion.
In WD-02, the MUST NOT appears on line 171. In WD-03, this has moved
to line 180.
Hmmm. A little puzzle. I cannot figure out what I originally meant
here.
If I'm not mistaken, though, use of an activationSpec should preclude
the use of both a connectionFactory and a destination element, but the
text doesn't read that way, so that would seem to be the error, and
could possibly be tangentially related to what I was trying to express
here. However, I do not understand JCA all that well, so it would be
good if someone who does looks at this.
It is also worth noting that the XML Schema in appendix A does not
capture this mutual exclusion - if activationSpec, !connectionFactory,
and vice-versa - use of a choice element would be appropriate here, I
think.
If someone else confirms my limited understanding of JCA, I'll happily
file an issue and a proposed resolution.
-Eric.
