← Prev in month ← Prev in thread
Next in thread → Next in month →

NEW ISSUE: binding.ws has unwanted normative statement about providingadditional metadata with web services binding

From
Eric Johnson <>
Date
2009-06-19T16:57:41+00:00
ID
Thread
NEW ISSUE: binding.ws has unwanted normative statement about providingadditional metadata with web services binding
Target: sca-binding-ws-spec-cd02-rev3.pdf

Description:

Line 265 - 266 (Section 2.5) of the spec has the text:

"SCA runtime implementations MAY provide additional
metadata that is associated with a web service binding."

Unfortunately,
it is difficult to figure
out what it was actually referring to.  The consensus on the mailing
list took this to mean that an SCA binding.ws element
might contain additional metadata to help configure non-SCA aspects of
a web-services binding.  However, that's not a necessary normative
constraint
on the runtime or the document, as the document already has normative
constraints about the schema.

Proposal:

Change the wording to: "SCA runtime
implementations can provide additional
metadata that is associated with a web service binding."

-Eric.
← Prev in month ← Prev in thread
Next in thread → Next in month →