Re: [sca-bindings] [BINDINGS-168] BWS20034 & BWS20036 are optionalnormative statements

Logged as: http://www.osoa.org/jira/browse/BINDINGS-168

    

    -Eric.

    

    On 6/8/11 6:07 AM, Mike Edwards wrote:
    
      
      

      Target:
         sca-wsbinding-1.1-cd04.pdf
      
      

      

      Description:  
      

      

      BWS20034 & BWS20036 are both
        optional
        normative statements - this gives problems in meeting the exit
        requirements
        and are not acceptable: 
      

      

      
        
          

            [BWS20034]
            
            The SCA runtime SHOULD
                support the WSDL 1.1
                binding extension for SOAP 1.2 over HTTP [W11-SOAP12],
                as identified
                by the WSDL element wsoap12:binding that has the
                @transport attribute with
                a value of "http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/soap/http".
            
          

          

            [BWS20036]
            
            The <bindingType>
                element associated
                with this binding SHOULD include the SOAP.v1_2 intent in
                its @mayProvides
                attribute.
          

        
      
      

      

      

      Proposal: 
      

      

      Make both statements
        non-normative,
        replacing them with the following text: 
      

      

      a)
      

      
The SCA runtime can support the
          WSDL 1.1 binding
          extension for SOAP 1.2 over HTTP [W11-SOAP12], as
          identified by
          the WSDL element wsoap12:binding that has the @transport
          attribute with
          a value of "http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/soap/http".
      

      

        

        b) 
        

        

        Where the binding
          implementation provides
          support for SOAP 1.2 over HTTP described above, it is good
          practice for
        the <bindingType>
          element associated
          with this binding to include the SOAP.v1_2 intent in its
          @mayProvides attribute.
        

         
        

        Yours, Mike 
        

        
          
            

              
                
                

                

              
            

            

              
                

              
            

            

              Dr Mike Edwards
              
               Mail
                  Point 137, Hursley
                  Park 
              
              
                

                

              
            

            

              STSM
                
              
               Winchester,
                  Hants SO21
                  2JN 
              
            

            

              SCA & Services
                  Standards 
              
               United
                  Kingdom
                
              
            

            

              Co-Chair OASIS SCA
                  Assembly TC 
              
               
                
              
              
                

              
            

            

              IBM Software Group
              
                 
              
              
                

              
            

            

              Phone:
                
              
              +44-1962
                  818014
                
              
                
              
              
                

              
            

            

              Mobile:
              
              +44-7802-467431
                  (274097)
                
              
                 
              
              
                

              
            

            

              e-mail:
                
              
              
                
              
                 
              
              
                

              
            

            

               
                
              
            

            

               
            

          
        
        

        

         
        

        

         
        

      

      
      

      

      

       
      

      

      Unless stated otherwise above:
      

      IBM United Kingdom Limited -
          Registered
          in England and Wales with number 741598. 
      

      Registered office: PO Box 41,
          North
          Harbour, Portsmouth, Hampshire PO6 3AU 
      

      

      

      

       
      

      

      

       

      
      

      

      
      

        

        
      
Unless stated otherwise
            above:

            IBM United Kingdom Limited - Registered in England and Wales
            with number
            741598. 

            Registered office: PO Box 41, North Harbour, Portsmouth,
            Hampshire PO6
            3AU