[NEW ISSUE] Problems with testcase JCA_7001

Target:   sca-j-caa-1.1-testcases-cd01.odt

Description:

There are several faults with the artifacts
of testcase JCA_7001:

1) JCA_7001_TestCase.java

Incorrect response string is declared:

         
config.output[0]            
     = "JCA_7001
request service1 operation1 invoked service2 operation1 invoked callback1
invoked other callbacks null";

It should be as follows:

         
  config.output[0]          
       = "JCA_7001
request service1 operation1 invoked "
+ 

         
                 
           "service2
operation3 invoked " + 

         
                 
           "service1
callback1 invoked " + 

         
                 
           "service1
callback1 invoked " +

         
                 
           "other
callbacks null";

2) Test_JCA_7001.composite

Incorrect descriptions of the components
(editorial changes only)

3) MultipleCallbacksImpl.java

Inadequate description of the implementation
(editorial change).

Incorrect response values from the operation3
and operation7 methods:

        /**

         *
Service
operation
for
Service3
which
invokes
an
operation
on
the
callback
Service3Callback

         */

        public
String operation3(String input) {

         
      String callbackResult = callback3.callback1("callback");

         
      String callbackResult2 = setterCallback3.callback1("callback2");

         
      String otherCallbacks = "other
callbacks null";

         
      if(
callback7 != null
|| setterCallback7 != null
) otherCallbacks = "other
callbacks also set";

         
      return
serviceName + "
operation1 invoked" + "
" + callbackResult + "
" + callbackResult2 + "
" + otherCallbacks;

        }

        /**

         *
Service
operation
for
Service7
which
invokes
an
operation
on
the
callback
Service7Callback

         */

        public
String operation7(String input) {

         
      String callbackResult = callback7.service7Callback1("callback");

         
      String callbackResult2 = setterCallback7.service7Callback1("callback2");

         
      String otherCallbacks = "other
callbacks null";

         
      if(
callback3 != null
|| setterCallback3 != null
) otherCallbacks = "other
callbacks also set";

         
      return
serviceName + "
operation1 invoked" + "
" + callbackResult + "
" + callbackResult2 + "
" + otherCallbacks;

        }

These methods should include their method
names in the response strings, not the name "operation1":

        /**

         *
Service
operation
for
Service3
which
invokes
an
operation
on
the
callback
Service3Callback

         */

        public
String operation3(String input) {

         
      String callbackResult = callback3.callback1("callback");

         
      String callbackResult2 = setterCallback3.callback1("callback2");

         
      String otherCallbacks = "other
callbacks null";

         
      if(
callback7 != null
|| setterCallback7 != null
) otherCallbacks = "other
callbacks also set";

         
      return
serviceName + "
operation3 invoked" + "
" + callbackResult + "
" + callbackResult2 + "
" + otherCallbacks;

        }

        /**

         *
Service
operation
for
Service7
which
invokes
an
operation
on
the
callback
Service7Callback

         */

        public
String operation7(String input) {

         
      String callbackResult = callback7.service7Callback1("callback");

         
      String callbackResult2 = setterCallback7.service7Callback1("callback2");

         
      String otherCallbacks = "other
callbacks null";

         
      if(
callback3 != null
|| setterCallback3 != null
) otherCallbacks = "other
callbacks also set";

         
      return
serviceName + "
operation7 invoked" + "
" + callbackResult + "
" + callbackResult2 + "
" + otherCallbacks;

        }

Proposal:

1) JCA_7001_TestCase.java

Change the response string to the second
form shown above

2) Test_JCA_7001.composite

Add the following descriptive paragraph:

"
This test is based on one component invoking a bidirectional service on
a second component, where that second

 component has two
different bidirectional services.  The test checks for both Field
and Setter injection of the

 callback
for the first service - it also checks to see that the Fields & Setters
for the second (not invoked) 

 service are set
to null."

3) MultipleCallbacksImpl.java

Change the return strings for the 2
methods to the second set of values shown above.

Yours,  Mike.

Strategist - Emerging Technologies, SCA & SDO.

Co Chair OASIS SCA Assembly TC.

IBM Hursley Park, Mail Point 146, Winchester, SO21 2JN, Great Britain.

Phone & FAX: +44-1962-818014    Mobile: +44-7802-467431  

Email:  

Unless stated otherwise above:

IBM United Kingdom Limited - Registered in England and Wales with number
741598. 

Registered office: PO Box 41, North Harbour, Portsmouth, Hampshire PO6
3AU