I ran the latest CSAR file (2015-06-14 tosca_elk_DRAFT_CSAR.zip) through my validator, and I have a couple more comments:
1.
There is an indentation error in logstash.yaml. Under the “search_endpoint” requirement, the capability, node, and relationship keynames should all be indented equally as follows:
node_types:
tosca.nodes.SoftwareComponent.Logstash:
derived_from: tosca.nodes.SoftwareComponent
requirements:
- search_endpoint:
capability: tosca.capabilities.Endpoint
node: tosca.nodes.SoftwareComponent.Elasticsearch
relationship:
2.
In tosca_elk.yaml, the mongo_db node template is missing the following required properties:
·
port
·
name
3.
There are a number of instances where operations in interfaces assign values to inputs that haven’t been previously defined. According to the spec, it is illegal to assign a value to an input that has not been previously defined. Here
are the instances:
·
In tosca_elk.yaml, the app_collectd node template defines the Configure operation of the Standard interface. Specifically, it defines an implementation but it also assigns a value to the “logstash_ip” input. However, the interface
definition does not define a “logstash_ip” input.
·
similarly, the kibana node template defines the Configure operation of the Standard interface. Specifically, it defines an implementation but it also assigns a value to the “kibana_ip” and “elasticsearch_ip” inputs. However, the
interface definition does not define a “kibana_ip” or “elasticsearch_ip” input.
·
Same problem with the app_rsyslog node template. It assigns a value to an undefined “logstash_ip” input.
·
Same problem with the mongo_dbms node template. It assigns a value to an undefined mongodb_ip input
Chris
