Re: [uddi-spec] Change request for deriving V2 key directly when V3key is a UUID key

I think it is reasonable to short-circuit the 
production of a V1/V2 key from a V3 uuidKey.  I am not sure I understand 
the relevance of "root key space" and "root registry" - is it not simply the 
case that if a V3 save is made that results in a V3 uuidKey then the mapping 
should apply and not the hashing, but if a UUID is used in any other context 
then the hashing would still apply?

 

I would add something to the beginning of 10.1.1 
rather than letting the reader wade through the algorithm and then tell them 
that it does not apply to V3 uuidKeys.

 

Do we not need a new policy definition?  I 
cannot see anything that says what approach is used to generate V1/V2 keys 
during a V3 save much less allowing for V3 uuidKeys to be treated 
differently.

 

John

  
----- Original Message ----- 

  
From: 
  Andrew Hately 
  

  
To:  
  

  
Sent: Friday, February 07, 2003 1:06 
  AM

  
Subject: [uddi-spec] Change request for 
  deriving V2 key directly when V3 key is a UUID key

  

Please find attached a change 
  request for review. 

Andrew Hately
IBM Austin
UDDI Development, Emerging 
  Technologies