Re: [ws-rx] NEW ISSUE - No indication of how to process NACKs in normalcase

Steve,

  +1 - although I'd prefer it to
be a MUST to be consistent with the text for AckRequested - but since its
really up to the RMS to determine when to do it anyway its not a huge thing.

thanks

-Doug

"Winkler, Steve"
<> 

09/06/2005 02:54 PM

To

<>

cc

Subject

[ws-rx] NEW ISSUE - No indication
of how to process NACKs in normal case

All, 

Here's a description of the new issue I wanted
to raise from the discussion of the related issue i005 [1].  

Title: Processing model of NACKs 

Description: Although it is assumed that a
NACK will trigger retransmission of a given message from the source to
the destination there is no wording in the current version of the spec
that describes this feature adequately.

Justification: This will clarify to implementers
the spriit of the spec by spelling out in more concrete terms what is currently
only implied.

Target: Core 

Type: Design 

Proposal: 

Add the following to the spec directly before
the text that is incorporated as a resolution to i005:

Upon the receipt of a Nack, an RM Source SHOULD
retransmit the message identified by the Nack as soon as possible. 

Cheers,

Steve 

[1] http://lists.oasis-open.org/archives/ws-rx/200508/msg00272.html

---------------------------

Steve Winkler 

SAP AG