Re: [wsrp] Re: [Fwd: Re: Question on Container Events]

For things like event names, the "wsrp:"
is not part of the name ... one good solution would be to define the prefix
as "wsrp" rather than "x", as in:

 <portlet-app>

    <portlet>

        ..............

         <supported-processing-event>

             <qname
xmlns:wsrp="urn:oasis:names:tc:wsrp:v2:types">

              
  wsrp:eventHandlingFailed

             </qname>

         </supported-processing-event>

    </portlet>

 </portlet-app>

Rich Thompson

OASIS WSRP TC Chair

IBM T.J. Watson Research Center / Hawthorne, NY

From:
Rajesh T <>

To:


Cc:
Deepak Gothe <>,


Date:
02/15/08 05:55 AM

Subject:
[wsrp] Re: [Fwd: Re: Question on Container
Events]

Just redirecting to the OASIS WSRP alias.

To summarize the issue

The JSR 286 spec point to the WSRP spec for Container
Events. i.e Container Events(PLT.15.3) points to WSRP spec (5.11)

Here is the snippet from WSRP spec

5.11 Defined Events

 This specification defines the following events
in the interest of

 promoting interoperability on a set of commonly
encountered scenarios.

 All of these are defined within the WSRP types namespace
(i.e.

 urn:oasis:names:tc:wsrp:v2:types).

 ---------------------------------------------------

Based on the above the following declaration the following
in portlet.xml:

 <portlet-app>

    <portlet>

        ..............

         <supported-processing-event>

             <qname
xmlns:x="urn:oasis:names:tc:wsrp:v2:types">

              
  x:wsrp:eventHandlingFailed

             </qname>

         </supported-processing-event>

    </portlet>

 </portlet-app>

results in a schema validation exception:

 org.xml.sax.SAXParseException: cvc-datatype-valid.1.2.1:

 'x:wsrp:eventHandlingFailed' is not a valid value
for 'QName'

Discussion on the JSR286 EG says:

depends on how we read this, it should just indicate that
the event is in the wsrp namespace.

i.e intepert the above as   x:eventHandlingFailed
 i.e drop wsrp:  since its not a valid QNAME

But this quite confusing since the WSRP spec in all the
places uses string like wsrp:view , 

wsrp:edit literally.

Comments ?

regards

Rajesh T 

On 14-Feb-08, at 7:29 PM, Deepak Gothe wrote:

From: Stefan Hepper <>

Date: 14 February 2008 6:38:07 PM GMT+05:30

To: 

Subject: Re: Question on Container Events

I think that is a discussion you should have on the WSRP mailing list.

I agree that it is a bit confusing, for the mode you need to include the
wsrp: prefix, for the events not. 

Regards,

   Stefan


wrote on 13.02.2008 12:00:45:

> In the rest of the WSRP spec, the items are interpreted literally,
say 

> for example "wsrp:view", "wsrp:edit" are the strings
that represent the 

> modes of the portlet in WSRP. Do you mean to say that we should 

> interpret these also the same way?

> 

> The above are not an issue because they are not used in namespace,

> rather as Strings. If you look at the WSRP webservice SOAP dump, you
can 

> see the above strings be passed as is.

> 

> Thanks,

> Deepak

> 

> Stefan Hepper wrote:

> > Depends on how you read this, it should just indicate that the
event is in

> > the wsrp namespace.

> >

> >

> > Regards,

> >     Stefan

> >

> >

> >

> >

> > Java Community Process JSR #286 Expert List <>
wrote on

> > 08.02.2008 04:54:20:

> >

> >   

> >> Thanks. This means the event name(wsrp:eventHandlingFailed)
defined in

> >> PLT.15.3 and that defined in WSRP spec 5.11 is incorrect.

> >>

> >> Regards,

> >> Deepak

> >>

> >> Stefan Hepper wrote:

> >>     

> >>> ":" is not allowed in a local part of the namespace,
it needs to be:

> >>>

> >>> <qname xmlns:x="urn:oasis:names:tc:wsrp:v2:types">

> >>>                
x:eventHandlingFailed

> >>> </qname>

> >>>

> >>> Regards,

> >>>     Stefan

> >>>

> >>>

> >>>

> >>>

> >>> Java Community Process JSR #286 Expert List <>
wrote

> >>>       

> > on

> >   

> >>> 07.02.2008 11:41:53:

> >>>

> >>>

> >>>       

> >>>> Hi,

> >>>>   I have a question regarding Container Events(PLT.15.3).
 Following

> >>>>         

> > is

> >   

> >>>> the snippet from WSRP spec (5.11)

> >>>> ---------------------------------------------------

> >>>> 5.11 Defined Events

> >>>> This specification defines the following events in
the interest of

> >>>> promoting interoperability on a set of commonly encountered
scenarios.

> >>>> All of these are defined within the WSRP types namespace
(i.e.

> >>>> urn:oasis:names:tc:wsrp:v2:types).

> >>>> ---------------------------------------------------

> >>>>

> >>>> Based on the above i declared the following in portlet.xml:

> >>>>

> >>>> <portlet-app>

> >>>>    <portlet>

> >>>>        ..............

> >>>>         <supported-processing-event>

> >>>>             <qname
xmlns:x="urn:oasis:names:tc:wsrp:v2:types">

> >>>>              
  x:wsrp:eventHandlingFailed

> >>>>             </qname>

> >>>>         </supported-processing-event>

> >>>>    </portlet>

> >>>> </portlet-app>

> >>>>

> >>>> Schema validation fails with the following message:

> >>>>

> >>>> org.xml.sax.SAXParseException: cvc-datatype-valid.1.2.1:

> >>>> 'x:wsrp:eventHandlingFailed' is not a valid value
for 'QName'

> >>>>

> >>>>

> >>>> Am i missing something? or can wsrp:eventHandlingFailed
be a valid

> >>>>         

> > name

> >   

> >>>> for the event or should it be something else?

> >>>>

> >>>>

> >>>> Thanks,

> >>>> Deepak

> >>>>

> >>>>         

>