Re: [xliff] Call For Dissent: Inline Markup within Change Tracking <item />

From
Phil Ritchie <>
Date
2016-08-15T07:09:23+00:00
ID
Thread
Re: [xliff] Call For Dissent: Inline Markup within Change Tracking <item />
Thanks Yves. I hand-coded the XLF hence the errors. I'll make the fixes and re-validate.

Phil

Twitter: philratwork

Skype: philviathecloud

Phil Ritchie

Chief Technology Officer | Vistatec

Vistatec House, 700 South Circular Road,

Kilmainham, Dublin 8, Ireland.

Tel: +353 1 416 8000 |
Direct:
+353 1 416 8024

Email:


www.vistatec.com |
 ISO 9001 | ISO 13485 | EN 15038

Think Global

   

On 15 Aug 2016, at 05:25, Yves Savourel <> wrote:

Hi Phil,

 

I’ve noticed 3 issues (at least I think they are issues) in the example file before getting to one on the <item> element that I was expecting since my build of Lynx doesn’t have your
 SD file included yet.

 

1) Issue with subFlowStart:

 

In <mtc:match ref="#m76"> there is a <target> with a code <pc id="2"> that has subFlowStart="", which I believe is not allowed by the schema.

 

 

2) Issue with xml:lang:

 

The <xliff> element has a xml:lang="en" attribute.

 

But the target language of the file is ‘de’ and the <target> elements do not overwrite the xml:lang of the <xliff>, therefore they are inherited and set to "en" instead of "de". The
 solution is to either remove the xml:lang in <xliff> or add xml:lang in the <target> elements.

 

3) Issue with <originalData>:

 

Several <mtc:match> elements have inline codes. But they have no corresponding <originalData>.

The <originalData> is only stored at the <unit> level, while according to the specification, <mtc:match> has its own <originalData>.

 

I hope that feedback helps,

-yves

 

 

 

From:  [mailto:]
On Behalf Of Phil Ritchie

Sent: Sunday, August 14, 2016 10:17 PM

To: 

Subject: [xliff] Call For Dissent: Inline Markup within Change Tracking <item />

 

 

Dear Committee Members

 

This is to deliver my

action item with regards to my 
proposal to allow storage of inline markup along with the text content of 
<source /> and
<target /> elements within Change Tracking
<item /> elements.

 

I attach the following in this email:

 

1.    
Sample XLIFF file (adapted from one in Bryan’s book).

2.    
Modified change_tracking.xsd. The main modification to this file is to insert an
<xs:group /> element within the definition of the
<item /> element which references back to XLIFF Core
<inline /> element group.

3.    
Proposed new text for the description of the
<item /> element in the specification.

 

I have validated my attached
punk-bands-ctr-with-inline.xlf by updating the XLIFF 2.0 schema hierarchy with my attached
change_tracking.xsd and validating with XMLSpy.

 

I hope we can discuss this at the next TC meeting on 16/8.

 

Phil

 

Phil Ritchie

Chief Technology Officer | Vistatec

Vistatec House, 700 South Circular Road,

Kilmainham, Dublin 8, Ireland.

Tel: +353 1 416 8000 | Direct: +353 1 416 8024

Email:



www.vistatec.com | ISO 9001 | ISO 13485 | EN 15038

<image002.png>

Think Global

<image004.jpg> <image006.jpg> <image008.jpg> <image010.jpg>

Vistatec Ltd. Registered in Ireland 268483.

Registered Office, Vistatec House, 700, South Circular Road, Kilmainham. Dublin 8. Ireland.

The information contained in this message, including any accompanying documents, is confidential and is intended only for the addressee(s). The unauthorized use, disclosure, copying, or alteration of this message is strictly forbidden. If you have received
 this message in error please notify the sender immediately.