Re: [xml-dev] more politics

From
Tim Bray <>
To
Dare Obasanjo <>
Date
2003-07-31T18:23:14Z
ID
<>
Thread
Re: [xml-dev] more politics
Dare Obasanjo wrote:

> The whole "GETs must be side effect free" is a spec bug as far as I'm concerned. I can understand saying that they should be idempotent but besides opening the door to a bunch of metaphysical discussions aboutt "what exactly constitutes a side effect" I don't see what purpose that part of the spec serves. 

Right.  Basically every GET writes a logfile record as a minimum.  I'm 
more comfy with language along the lines of "GET does not incur new 
obligations."  Which is actually functionally necessary for caches and 
proxies to work. -Tim