Re: [xml-dev] Best Practice for URI construction?

From
bryan rasmussen <>
To
Bjoern Hoehrmann <>
Date
2005-12-10T21:19:14Z
ID
<>
Thread
Re: [xml-dev] Best Practice for URI construction?
> >a link doesn't work. As an example, if
> >
> >http://somewhere.org/US/IL/
> >
> >is a valid URL, then truncating this to
> >
> >http://somewhere.org/US/
> >
> >should both work and provide meaningful information.
>
> People who do this commit web architecture crime, the TAG commands
> "People making use of URIs SHOULD NOT attempt to infer properties
> of the referenced resource".
>

Are you arguing that a portion of a path that makes up a part of
another path should be able to return a 404?

I can understand a portion of a path returns some other error, or course.

that is to say
http://somewhere.org/US/IL/
is a 200
but
http://somewhere.org/US/
is not found?

Because I would argue that with a longer path which is found I can
infer that all the parts of that path are found as well.