Re: [xri] Top Ten XRI Requirements

From
Oeter D Eavis
Date
2003-02-07T16:50:21+00:00
ID
Thread
Re: [xri] Top Ten XRI Requirements
Drummond Reed wrote:
<snip/>
> 5) Peer-to-peer: the ability for any resource to serve as its own root
> identifier authority (i.e., no centralized or absolute authority required).
> 
> 6) Unlimited federation: the ability for identifier authority to be
> delegated to any depth. 
> 
> 7) Context addressability: the ability for a resource to be identified in
> the context of another resource.
><snip/>

I am not certain that the "federation" decsription is quite in line with 
the industries (recent) understanding of the term. Here, as stated, it 
implies a heirarchical relationship, but federations (as defined in my 
mind based on the Liberty Alliance activities and working definitions), 
is more closely related to peer-to-peer.  that si to say:

Unlimited Federation: allows for the identifier authority to construct 
arbitrary associations with other authorities identifiers.

I think this is more consitant with want is reflected, then, in items 5 
and 7

-- 
--- peterd
Sr Security Architect
Neustar, Inc.		smtp:   
(571) 434 5516		jabber: 

<Quote type="random">
Touch a scientist and you touch a child.
<Author>Ray Bradbury</Author>
</Quote>

PGP Fingerprint:
8994 8774 B682 3A04 B304  C4A2 D9DD 7E5B 8AAC 2D00