Is the behavior correct?

I have run some examples through BARKS

First query:

http://xrisoft.net:4000/@ootao*steven?_xrd_r=application/xrds+xml%3Bsep=true&demo=true

We see a ref to the CID of =steven at the XRD level of *steven.
 

http://xrisoft.net:4000/@ootao*steven?_xrd_t=http://openid.net/signon/1.0&_xrd_r=application/xrd+xml%3Bsep=true&demo=true

This produces a XRD with the CID of =steven not @ooTao*steven.  

−

	<XRD version="2.0">

<Query>!C5FB.53B6.6E94.824</Query>

<ServerStatus code="100"/>

<Status code="100" cid="verified"/>

<Expires>2007-10-25T23:06:35Z</Expires>

<ProviderID>xri://=</ProviderID>

<LocalID priority="10">!C5FB.53B6.6E94.824</LocalID>

<CanonicalID priority="10">=!C5FB.53B6.6E94.824</CanonicalID>

−

	<Service priority="0">

<Type select="true">http://openid.net/signon/1.0</Type>

<URI priority="1" append="qxri">https://2idi.com/openid/</URI>

<URI priority="2" append="qxri">http://2idi.com/openid/</URI>

</Service>

</XRD>
 

I believe this to be correct. 

However if we try.

http://xrisoft.net:4000/@ootao*steven?_xrd_t=xri://+i-service*(+contact)*($v*1.0)&_xrd_r=application/xrd+xml%3Bsep=true&demo=true

We get:

−

	<XRD>

<Query>*steven</Query>

<ServerStatus code="100">SUCCESS</ServerStatus>

<Status code="100" cid="verified">SUCCESS</Status>

<ProviderID>xri://!!1003</ProviderID>

<LocalID>!0000.0000.3B9A.CA16</LocalID>

<CanonicalID>@!5BAD.2AA.3C72.AF46!0000.0000.3B9A.CA16</CanonicalID>

<Ref>=!C5FB.53B6.6E94.824</Ref>

−

	<xrd:Service priority="0">

<xrd:ProviderID>xri://!!1003!103</xrd:ProviderID>

<xrd:Type select="true">xri://+i-service*(+contact)*($v*1.0)</xrd:Type>

<xrd:Type match="null"/>

<xrd:Path select="true">(+contact)</xrd:Path>

<xrd:Path match="null"/>

<xrd:URI priority="1" append="authority">http://linksafe-contact.ezibroker.net/contact/</xrd:URI>

</xrd:Service>

</XRD>

The ref is not followed.   I think this is a holdover from WD10 where where the ref at the XRD level was not followed if SEP is matched in the XRD.

Should the correct result have been?:

−

	<XRDS ref="xri://=C5FB.53B6.6E94.824">

−

	<XRD>

<Query>*C5FB.53B6.6E94.824</Query>

<Status code="222">The subsegment does not exist</Status>

<Expires>2007-10-25T23:23:48.000Z</Expires>

<ProviderID>xri://=</ProviderID>

</XRD>

</XRDS>
 

This is no Fault of BARKS it is doing what I thought it should be doing before our conversation earlier today.

So is everyone clear that SEPS in a XRD are never processed if there is a ref at the XRD level?

=ve7jtb

 
 
 

smime.p7s