[xslt-conformance] Re: tests submissions

Hi All:

I have one question: which status
code ('s1' - 's6') to use? Carmelo

used s5 in the sample xml file. Now, when a test has been reviewed by
2

people, which is the appropriate status?

   David, please correct me if am wrong on any of the
fallowing

   observations:

        1)
If your decision and the decision of the other reviewer

           
are that the test is ok, then I would think that the correct

  
         status
will be "s1", which indicates acceptance.

        2) If the
two decisions are not the same, then I would think that

                
the correct status will be "s0", which indicates no
concensus.

What if I have some comments and/or
if I've found an XSLT processor,

which produces different results than those of other XSLT
processors?

        You can put your comments in
the "comments" element.  It is quite

         possible that two
processors can render different results, however that

         is really beyond the
scope of our analysis in terms of accepting, rejecting

         ..., etc a
test.   

        Your decision on accepting a
test is based on your observing (looking)

         at the test and decide
if the test is correct as is.

         Hope this
helps.

Cheers,

Dimitre Novatchev.

--- Carmelo Montanez <> wrote:

> Hi all:

> 

>          Basically the
procedure the review  the tests is very

> simple.

>                 
1) Inform me of which tests you wish to review.

>                 
2)  Manually inspect the test.

>                 
3) Will be helpful if the tests are run (I used two 

> implementations),

>                     
however reviewers are free to use any (correct

> me if I

>                     
am wrong David).

>                 
4) The findings can be submitted to me on an XML

> format

>                      
file (see attached file for example of the one

> I 

> used).   I do

>                      
not have a DTD for it, however it is a simple

> file.

>                 
5) I will post the findings on the web site on an

> HTML format.

>                 
6) The committee will make a decision on the final

> status

>                      
of the test (removal, send to W3c for further 

> revision, leave

>                      
as is etc).

> 

> Thanks,

> Carmelo

> 

> 

>                         

> ATTACHMENT part 2 application/xml name=reviewedTests.xml

__________________________________________________

Do You Yahoo!?

Yahoo! Health - Feel better, live better

http://health.yahoo.com