Re: [sca-bindings] [BINDINGS-167] WSCB has separate conformance pointsin the Web services specification

Logged as: http://www.osoa.org/jira/browse/BINDINGS-167

    

    -Eric.

    

    On 6/8/11 5:58 AM, Mike Edwards wrote:
    
      
      

      Target:
         sca-wsbinding-1.1-cd04.pdf
        

      

        Description: 
      

      

      Sections 6.2 & 6.3 describe 2
        separate
        conformance points within the Web services binding
        specification:
      

      
6.2        Web
            Service Callback Service
      

      
An implementation that claims to
          conform to
          the requirements of a WSCB Service defined in this
          specification MUST conform
          to all the statements in Appendix C: Conformance Items related
          to a WSCB
          Service.
      

      
6.3        Web
            Service Callback Client
      

      
An implementation that claims to
          conform to
          the requirements of a WSCB Client defined in this
          specification MUST conform
          to all the statements in Appendix C: Conformance Items related
          to a WSCB
          Client.
      

      

        

        

        -- This is problematic in terms of
          the exit
          criteria and the potentially (very) large number of
          combinations of runtimes
          required.
        

        

        Proposal:
        

        

        2 alternatives:
        

        

        a) Remove both of these
          conformance
          points and make any SCA Runtime implement WSCB (Client &
          Server)
        

        

        b) Remove WSCB as a whole into
          a separate
          specification with its own conformance requirements.
        

        

        

        
        

        Yours, Mike
        

        
          
            

              
                
              
            

            

              
                

              
            

            

              Dr Mike Edwards
              
               Mail
                  Point 137, Hursley
                  Park
              
              
                

              
            

            

              STSM
              
               Winchester,
                  Hants SO21
                  2JN
              
            

            

              SCA & Services
                  Standards
              
               United
                  Kingdom
              
            

            

              Co-Chair OASIS SCA
                  Assembly TC
              
               
              
              
                

              
            

            

              IBM Software Group
              
                
              
              
                

              
            

            

              Phone:
              
              +44-1962
                  818014
              
                
              
              
                

              
            

            

              Mobile:
              
              +44-7802-467431
                  (274097)
              
                
              
              
                

              
            

            

              e-mail:
              
              
              
                
              
              
                

              
            

            

               
              
            

            

               
            

          
        
        

        

        
        

        

        
      

      

        

        
      
Unless stated otherwise
            above:

            IBM United Kingdom Limited - Registered in England and Wales
            with number
            741598. 

            Registered office: PO Box 41, North Harbour, Portsmouth,
            Hampshire PO6
            3AU
      

      

          

        
        

        

        

          

        
        

        

        
      

      

        

        
      
Unless stated otherwise
            above:

            IBM United Kingdom Limited - Registered in England and Wales
            with number
            741598. 

            Registered office: PO Box 41, North Harbour, Portsmouth,
            Hampshire PO6
            3AU
      

      

          

        
        

        

        

          

        
        

        

        
      

      

        

        
      
Unless stated otherwise
            above:

            IBM United Kingdom Limited - Registered in England and Wales
            with number
            741598. 

            Registered office: PO Box 41, North Harbour, Portsmouth,
            Hampshire PO6
            3AU
      

      

          

        
        

        

        

          

        
        

        

        
      

      

        

        
      
Unless stated otherwise
            above:

            IBM United Kingdom Limited - Registered in England and Wales
            with number
            741598. 

            Registered office: PO Box 41, North Harbour, Portsmouth,
            Hampshire PO6
            3AU